
University of Cincinnati quarterback Dustin Grutza didn’t expect to play in the final regular season game of 2008 at Hawaii, but after starter Tony Pike left the game after throwing two interceptions, the backup came into the game with 6:37 in the fourth quarter and his team down 24-20, and led the Bearcats to a 29-24 come-from-behind win.
“(Grutza) has had a tough career altogether,” said UC quarterbacks coach Greg Forest, when asked about Grutza’s setbacks this season. “Even when he started before we got here, he took his licks and got beat up a little bit and came back and every chance he’s had. He just hangs in there and has a lot of character and he’s bounced back every time.”
It’s been that kind of a season for the Bearcat quarterbacks this season. Five different quarterbacks have played in 2008 and three have started – mainly due to injury.
Grutza began the year as starter after backing up QB Ben Mauk all of last season, but badly broke his leg in the season’s second game, a loss at Oklahoma, 52-26. Pike was then appointed the starter and led UC to a win over Miami before breaking his arm the next game at Akron. Redshirt freshman Chazz Anderson filled in nicely as the starting quarterback the next week in a convincing win over Marshall, 33-10. The other two quarterbacks to see action this season are freshman quarterback, Zach Collaros and the sophomore transfer from Notre Dame, Demetrius Jones.
After redshirting in 2004, Dustin Grutza went on to start 21 games in the next two seasons for the Bearcats throwing for 20 touchdowns and over 3000 yards in that span. Grutza made way for Wake Forest transfer Ben Mauk in 2006, and had eagerly anticipated starting again this season. He started his comeback season by completing 21-28 passes for 296 yards and three touchdowns in the opener against Eastern Kentucky but then sustained his injury the following week at Oklahoma.

Enter Tony Pike. While seeing limited action in his first two seasons after redshirting as a freshman, Pike found himself under center for the majority of what has become the best football season in the school’s history. Quarterbacks coach Greg Forest talked about how he thought Pike has improved the most this season.
“It’s his leadership and getting that game experience. Any time you get game experience it definitely helps you in feeling more confident with what you’re doing out there,” said Forest.
Pike came in late in the blowout loss to Oklahoma -- a game that was over by the time Grutza went down with a broken leg. After throwing three touchdowns in his first career start against Miami (OH), Pike broke his left arm in the fourth quarter against Akron, an injury that required surgery.
“They fixed the break and attached a six inch plate and six screws under the bone, and those are staying forever,” Pike explained.
The two injured quarterbacks spent the next three weeks together rehabilitating their broken limbs and trying to get back on the field. Pike said he learned from Grutza’s work ethic in that time.
“Just being able to sit down with Dustin the time I was out, I got to see how hard he works in the training room and what he goes through,” said Pike. “That’s what Dustin’s all about. He’s always worked hard here and he’s always been a patient guy and when he gets his chance, he gets in there and succeeds.”
The hard work paid off for Pike too as he missed only two games, and went on to lead the ‘Cats to six wins in seven games. He was second in the Big East in passing efficiency and completion percentage and threw for 18 touchdowns in 11 games.
Meanwhile, Grutza was undergoing his rehabilitation faster than most expected and seemed determine to rejoin the team before the season finished.
“It was a lot of rehab every single day,” said Grutza.
When he first broke his leg, reports suggested he may miss the remainder of the schedule, but Grutza had other plans.
He was the first one in the trainer’s room in the morning and the last one to leave at night. He admitted that in order to be 100 percent he would have to undergo another surgery on his leg, but opted to do so after the season.
“There was no guarantee that he would make it back this season. He worked hard and put himself in a position and you saw it come out in Louisville,” Pike said of Grutza. “When I went out with a bruised sternum, he was able to come in a carry the offense on a touchdown drive.”
Head Coach Brian Kelly has talked this season about having a “what have you done for me lately” mentality, so Grutza wanted to be ready in case Kelly ever gave him the nod again. Due to the injuries to both signal-callers throughout the season, each has had their share of game preparation and practice with the first-team offense.
“I think me and Dustin bring a lot of the same things to the table,” Pike said. “He was getting most of the reps the first week of our summer camps and when he went down with a rib injury, I went to get a lot of the (first-team) reps and we really didn’t have to change the offense a lot. With me or Dustin in there, the offense doesn’t change much and the coaches have the confidence to call any play for us”
The value of that confidence paid off in Hawaii, as Grutza led an offense that had struggled in the second half under Tony Pike, to a comeback win and sustained the team’s momentum heading into the Orange Bowl on Jan.1, 2009, against Virginia Tech.
That game will mark the end of Grutza’s career with the Bearcats, but Pike feels the success of this year’s quarterback play will continue in 2009.
“I think our success definitely has a carry over effect and hopefully after this season it will keep snowballing and carry into next year.”